First, check out the Wikipedia entry on biological uplift (although this entry could use a lot of work).
Second, there's my paper from a few years back, "All Together Now: Developmental and ethical considerations for biologically uplifting nonhuman animals." My basic argument is that we should strongly consider the inclusion of nonhuman animals into postbiological space. The more the merrier, I say.
Third, be sure to check out (or review) David's seminal work on the matter from a fictional perspective, namely his Uplift Series. Books in this collection include:
- Sundiver (1980)
- Startide Rising (1983)
- The Uplift War (1987)
- The Uplift Storm Trilogy
- Brightness Reef (1995)
- Infinity's Shore (1996)
- Heaven's Reach (1998)
Lastly, check out some of the work done by Sue Savage-Rumbaugh and the Great Ape Trust. Just to be clear, Sue is not an advocate of biological uplift, but the work that she does integrating bonobos into non-traditional living environments and in comprehending their language and culture speaks directly to this issue; there's a very fine line between cultural and biological uplift. For starters, check out the article, "Sue Savage-Rumbaugh on the welfare of apes in captivity." Also be sure to check out the work of the Great Ape Trust.
And while we're on this topic: please support the work done by the Great Ape Project and advocate for the inclusion of great apes into the personhood spectrum.
I must say, I do not see any reason to uplift animals. I work purely out of reason, not out of sympathy, compassion or sentiment. Moreover I do not agree with the notions of ethical or moral considerations, since both are an extremely flawed way for one to live their life. However I respect an individual intrinsic freedom. So if a scientist does chose to uplift his or her’s pet chimpanzee I am not going to protest about it.
I think that talk of uplifting animals gives h+ something of a bad name. There's nothing wrong with it, but it seems weird and frivolous.
The much more urgent and morally compelling challenges of friendly AI and reducing existential risks deserve your blog space much more.
Post a Comment